EU plant protein plans: sustainable for who?

Written by Chris Chancellor

Amid growing evidence of the far-reaching consequences of our global food system, reform of the current global agrifood supply-chain is increasingly being demanded from scholars, activists, farmers, and society at large. Concerns extend beyond the environmentally harmful aspects of food production, but also issues related to food and nutritional security, human health, social justice, and the concentration of control over land and other relevant markets.

Partly in response to these demands, as well as in line with its geopolitical interests, the European Union (EU) has made steps towards a sustainable plant protein strategy. Plant protein supply in the EU is currently heavily reliant on imports of soybean from Latin America’s Southern Cone region. This leaves the European livestock sector, the ultimate destination of almost all of these imports, vulnerable to volatile international markets and shifting geopolitical dynamics such as increasing demand from China for Latin American soy.

It would appear that these plans centre on expanding soybean production within the EU and neighbouring countries. However, the nature of this proposed production seems worryingly vague. In addition, visions of ‘efficiency’ and ‘sustainability’ remain inadequately narrow, as do understandings of food security. Ultimately, these seem to remain centred on yield per hectare valuations, albeit with a ‘sustainable’ veneer. This report calls for a more inclusive understanding of these concepts to form the basis of EU attempts towards food system reform, including explicit considerations of who controls food systems.

In the context of EU protein crop expansion, a control-blind approach to efficiency and sustainability is evident. There is a focus on headline hitting topics such as non-GM produce and reducing deforestation, as well as the fact that soy is a legume. These are not unimportant, and the fact that they receive political attention is in many ways a sign of progress. However, in isolation, they do not equate to environmentally and socially sustainable supply-chains. How this new soy supply is produced, distributed and consumed, as well as who controls the relevant markets and processes, holds the key for inclusively sustainable food systems.

Two useful concepts in pushing more inclusive food systems thinking are agroecology and food sovereignty. Whilst these concepts and related practices offer a promising alternative pathway, they cannot make a meaningful contribution without political support. European agricultural policy must nurture and facilitate a transition away from the concentrated industrial model that currently dominates. In order to do so, EU protein strategies, and wider food system reform in general, must therefore be based on broader, interconnected, and inclusive understandings of efficiency and sustainability.


Front Cover


Pastoralism under Threat: SAGCOT in Tanzania

Written by Flora Sonkin

“Pastoralism under Threat: Human Rights Violations in the Southern Agriculture Growth Corridor of Tanzania” is a policy brief by Terra Nuova, CELEP and Hands on the Land for Food Sovereignty, which analyzes, with a human rights approach, violations to the detriment of the many shepherds and small-scale farmers in Tanzania.

A recent fact-finding mission uncovered a series of forced evictions, cattle raids and personal violence against pastoralist communities, with serious consequences from the point of view of human right to food. These violations are related to the implementation of so-called corridors “for agricultural growth”, plans that envisage the creation of large infrastructures at the service of industrial and export agriculture, linked to foreign investments, which in the case explored by this brief, did not fulfil the process of Free Prior and Informed Consent of local populations and thus does not reflect the needs and interests of these communities.

In particular, the document analyzes the case of the Southern Agricultural Growth Corridor of Tanzania (SAGCOT), a project supported by the New Alliance for Food Security and Nutrition.

PDF: Pastoralism Under Threat